What question does the test answer?
It asks what you would inherit if you took over the service desk on the first day of next month. A reported active count tells you little about how many calls you must run or how much cash will arrive to fund them.
The Membership Delivery Test is a review of an HVAC agreement cohort that ties renewal eligibility, cleared payments, service obligations and delivered margin to the same customers over the same dates.
Sit down with the person who schedules maintenance. Ask them to select one route and show which visits are due this week. Then ask accounting to show when those specific customers last paid. When two systems identify a customer differently, use a location or contract number to connect them. A surname by itself will mix households, landlords and tenants.
Which records belong in the test?
Collect an export of the agreement register, billing history, settled payments, refunds and completed work orders for the same period. Keep the original exports read-only so someone else can repeat your selections when a question comes up.
| Record | What you need to see | A discrepancy to investigate |
|---|---|---|
| Agreement | Start, end, equipment and promised service | Same plan ID on two addresses |
| Renewal bill | Due date, gross price and discount | Payment dated before the renewal window |
| Settlement | Receipt, refund and chargeback | A failed card still marked current |
| Work order | Location, visit type and completion date | A booked visit counted as complete |
| Job cost | Loaded labor, drive time and supplies | Zero labor cost on a completed tune-up |
The dispatcher can explain why one address appears under a spouse’s name or why a visit moved to the following month. Record the explanation against the transaction. Then ask whether it affects one row or every account imported during a software migration.
How do you test renewal without counting new sales?
Freeze the opening cohort at the start of its renewal window. Give a late payer a defined grace period, use the same cutoff for everyone and show new sales on a different line. A new installation plan can replace a lost account in your cash forecast while the original cohort is still shrinking.
- Pull every agreement due to expire in the chosen period.
- Find the next paid period for each agreement and match a cleared receipt.
- Flag customers who transferred, paused, canceled, received a free extension or moved.
- Compute paid renewals divided by eligible expirations. Show unresolved accounts separately.
- Revisit the cohort after the grace period and document how the count changed.
Illustrative composite — not a real client. You have 100 agreements due in June. Seventy renew by the stated cutoff, ten new households enroll and five payments remain disputed. Your verified on-time renewal rate is 70 divided by 100, or 70%. New enrollments bring in cash, but they provide no evidence that any of the original customers stayed.
What does delivery cost before the next renewal?
Price the work you still owe. If your annual fee includes two visits, start with the unperformed visit count on individual contracts. The retail price of a tune-up does not tell you how much it costs to send your truck.
Suppose 24 paid visits remain on the schedule. In an illustrative estimate, each requires 75 minutes of paid field time including travel at a loaded hourly cost of $40, plus $8 in supplies. Each visit then costs $58, or $1,392 for the remaining schedule. Add incremental overtime if the renewal cohort lands in peak replacement season. Compare this cash requirement with the agreement balance in the closing statement. Your CPA can explain the company’s revenue recognition policy and any difference between the accounting liability and your cost forecast.
What do you do with the result?
If you’re selling, show the buyer the open visit schedule alongside the renewal cohort and the actual cash receipts. Your best explanation for an unusual account is a record the buyer can reproduce.
If you’re buying, ask whether the price already assumes a strong recurring book. Applying a separate multiple premium on top of an earnings multiple selected for the same agreements can count one advantage twice. Before you reopen price, distinguish a timing mismatch you can document from permanent customer losses or unfunded hours you must supply.
How do you handle a plan that covers several systems or locations?
Build the service obligation from the equipment schedule and contract language, then connect it to the account that paid. One customer can buy a plan covering two systems at one address. A property manager can sign a single agreement that covers several buildings. Counting either arrangement once as a member is reasonable for customer reporting. Counting it once when you estimate service hours can materially understate the work promised.
Take a two-building commercial account. Assume the agreement calls for one quarterly visit to each building, and the cut-off falls after the first quarter’s visits have been completed. Three visits remain at each building, six in total. If the larger site requires two technicians for three hours and the smaller site requires one technician for two hours, the remaining field requirement is three times six hours plus three times two hours, or 24 technician-hours. Add the actual travel, documentation and site-access time. A report showing six visits without crew size would conceal the reason this route consumes a lead technician.
Compare your estimate with completed work. The contract might list twenty rooftop units while the service notes consistently mention eighteen. Ask whether two units were removed, are inaccessible, fall under another vendor or were mistakenly skipped. Do not treat the difference as a saving until the agreement and service manager support the revised scope. If the company has been under-delivering, your buyer may inherit the cost of correcting the shortfall and the customer relationship.
How should monthly, annual and promotional plans be compared?
Use a separate schedule for each billing and service pattern. The annual cohort has specific renewal dates. Monthly customers can remain contractually current yet stop paying after a declined charge, and a promotional household can receive its first visit with no cash payment. Build a beginning-to-ending paid-account reconciliation that shows additions, renewals, cancellations, recovered charges and reactivations on distinct lines. Show gifts, discounts and free warranty-related visits separately.
For example, begin a month with 300 paid monthly accounts. Twenty new households make an initial payment, twelve cancel, eight payments fail and five of those failures clear within the defined recovery window. Assuming no other changes, the closing paid book is 305. Do not count the five recovered charges as five newly acquired households. If six free installation packages also enter the scheduling system, the dispatcher might now see 311 active service relationships. Both numbers can be correct for different purposes. Your cash forecast needs the 305 paying accounts, and your field schedule needs the obligations attached to all 311.
Check elapsed time before declaring churn. A customer billed on the last day of the month might clear after a weekend or bank holiday. Establish a consistent cut-off and retain the original as-of report instead of changing the past each time a payment arrives. Then report subsequent recoveries explicitly. The buyer can judge collection reliability, while the seller can demonstrate an ordinary timing pattern with bank evidence.
When does a maintenance visit improve or reduce overall contribution?
Calculate the direct economics of the promise and then analyze follow-on jobs separately. A household may pay an annual fee for two visits, priority response and parts discounts. Compare collected plan fees with field labor, travel, supplies, processing and customer benefits you expect to provide. A replacement sale can add later contribution, but its revenue and costs belong to a separate job. The framework works when you can explain both results without charging a customer twice or attributing the same profit to two parts of your valuation.
Look at an illustrative group of forty households paying $220 annually, for $8,800 if all payments clear. If two annual visits per household each cost $58 on the assumptions above, the direct service cost is $4,640. Suppose processing and other attributable plan servicing cost another $560 and member discounts on paid repairs total $720. The simplified remaining contribution is $2,880 before other overhead or extra demands. If the visit cost already includes processing or the reported repair margin already reflects the discounts, adjust the calculation so you deduct each item only once.
Timing changes this result. In March your shop might have spare hours for much of the delivery. In July the same paid hours could require overtime or displace an urgent repair. Ask the dispatcher to map remaining appointments onto actual crew availability by week, including cancellations, no-shows and households requiring a second technician. Show an ordinary and a stressed schedule. You can then see whether pricing, routing, customer frequency or seasonal scheduling creates the most practical opportunity to improve cash and service together.
Which exceptions should change the closing decision?
Resolve each exception according to its effect on ownership, money or the customer promise. An account linked under a spouse’s name may require only a corrected crosswalk. An expiring commercial agreement may call for a renewal discussion under the seller’s confidentiality process. A payment processor that requires fresh authorization can delay cash, while an overdue service obligation may require immediate labor even if the customer never renews. Assign a distinct action and avoid applying the same blanket discount to every exception.
Prepare a handoff with the account identifier, paid-through date, remaining service, next bill date, equipment, contact permissions and responsible dispatcher. Include a reserve or adjustment only after checking the working-capital definitions and any amounts already in the purchase price. Agree who contacts a household with an unresolved billing authorization and who resolves a complaint about a visit promised before closing. Reconcile the first post-close billing batch and the first completed route back to your frozen cohort. If both match, you have evidence that the buyer inherited not only a list, but a functioning service relationship.
Where can you go next?
What else should you know?
Do I count customers with more than one system twice?
Use the unit your contract actually sells. If one household buys two separate plans, track two plans and one household. If one plan covers both systems, record one agreement and two service obligations. Keep both location and equipment identifiers so you can explain the difference.
What if a member skipped a visit?
Read the agreement for expiration, cancellation and rescheduling rights, then check the service history for attempts to contact the customer. A missed visit could expire, roll forward or trigger a refund. State which result your model assumes and ask your attorney about any disputed promise.
Can I count replacement jobs as membership revenue?
Keep installation revenue in its own line. You can measure whether members buy more replacements, but label that as an observed relationship. Match installed jobs to eligible households and dates, remove canceled proposals, and subtract the cost of delivering those jobs before modeling additional earnings.
How large should my audit sample be?
Start with a group whose scheduled renewals you can trace end to end. Include failed payments, discounts and canceled accounts alongside successful renewals. Expand the sample when results differ across branches, billing systems or sales channels. Have your diligence team set materiality for the full book.
Which sources informed this page?
- Quality maintenance of residential HVAC systems · ACCA, November 21, 2026
- HVAC business valuation by operator tier · CT Acquisitions, July 14, 2026
- Contractor Playbook, chapter 13: KPIs and tracking · ServiceTitan, November 21, 2026
