Replacement conversion rate is the percentage of defined HVAC replacement opportunities that reach a specified sales or installation milestone within a stated observation period.
What counts as a replacement opportunity?
Choose a point in the customer journey and give it a precise name. A technician may identify a system that appears suitable for replacement, the customer may agree to an appointment, an adviser may present options and the homeowner may sign. Each step has a different denominator. You can measure the proportion of qualified leads producing a signed sale or the proportion of presented estimates resulting in an installation. Label the chart with both endpoints.
A service technician typically meets many customers who have no need for a new system. Dividing sold installations by all service calls tells you what share of visits produced a sale. It combines equipment age, call type, technician lead identification, booking and adviser close rate. When you want to understand a salesperson’s performance, use opportunities the individual actually received and had a reasonable chance to close.
Establish one opportunity identifier for the customer’s purchasing decision. Good, better and best proposals for the same heat pump are alternative offers. Counting each as a separate lead could cut the reported close rate by two-thirds even if the homeowner chooses a package. Distinguish a second system at the same location when it represents a separate decision with its own scope and timing.
How do you build the sales funnel?
Follow job identifiers from the original service ticket to the estimate, signed contract, scheduled installation, completed job and collected invoice. Keep event dates. An adviser might sign a contract in June for work performed in July, with the finance company paying after customer acceptance. A sales report grouped by signature and an income statement grouped by completion can both be right while showing different results.
ServiceTitan’s public playbook separates service lead generation from comfort-adviser close rate, while its dashboard documentation explains which opportunities and sold thresholds individual reports use. The playbook’s stated targets describe its operating guidance. Before adopting any target, compare the underlying call mix, report settings and sales stage with your business. A referral from a long-standing plan customer differs materially from a price-shopping lead booked from advertising.
Use a fixed opportunity cohort and give it enough time to mature. Open proposals issued in the last few days of a reporting month have less opportunity to close. Show these separately, then update the cohort after a stated period. An aging report can reveal a practical problem such as a missed follow-up or an estimate awaiting an electrical upgrade price.
How do two plausible conversion rates describe one shop?
Illustrative composite — not a real client. In a ninety-day cohort, technicians identify 125 replacement leads. One hundred customers receive a written proposal, 58 sign and 53 installations finish before the observation cutoff. Three customers cancel after signing and two jobs remain scheduled. The company counted each homeowner decision once, even when several equipment options were quoted.
| Question | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Lead to proposal | 100 ÷ 125 | 80.0% |
| Proposal to signed sale | 58 ÷ 100 | 58.0% |
| Signed to completed installation | 53 ÷ 58 | 91.4% |
| Lead to completed installation | 53 ÷ 125 | 42.4% |
Suppose each completed installation averages $11,400 in revenue and $3,650 of direct gross profit. The completed cohort represents $604,200 of revenue and $193,450 of direct gross profit. The two pending jobs have a different status. A buyer estimating next month’s cash should confirm equipment deliveries, crew slots, permitting and customer finance approval before treating either as available money.
What causes the sales report to disagree with job costing?
Start your review with canceled contracts, duplicate estimates, partial installations, discounts added after the sale and jobs assigned to a different branch. Confirm that refunds and credit memos follow the correct original job. A high close rate based on signed proposals can coexist with falling gross profit if installation crews need unquoted duct repairs or if dealer finance fees rise.
Review a sample across wins and losses. For a win, compare the original quote, signed design, final invoice, material usage and actual crew hours. For a loss, inspect the recorded reason and any follow-up. Calling an opportunity lost to price can conceal an adviser arriving late, a long permit delay or customer concerns about system sizing. Record what the file supports and label unknown outcomes explicitly.
How does ownership transition affect the number?
Identify who originates leads, sells major replacements and resolves objections. If the owner personally closes most high-ticket estimates, the company-wide figure can hide that dependency. Recalculate close rates by adviser, lead source and service territory. For your analysis, compare similar opportunity types before attributing the entire difference to the individual. Larger jobs may be assigned disproportionately to the owner.
A buyer can test continuity with a handoff period in which another adviser attends sales visits and records outcomes. Agree in advance who contacts customers and how the seller’s participation will be documented. The buyer should also inspect installation capacity. Increasing signed sales is of limited benefit if the next available crew is several weeks away and customers cancel to secure faster service elsewhere.
How do you evaluate an adviser receiving unusually strong leads?
Segment opportunities by their source before you compare people. A warm referral from a trusted technician and a homeowner requesting a fourth price quote give advisers different starting positions. Include territory, equipment age, emergency status, lead source and whether an existing membership is involved. Comparing advisers with very different mixes can reward favorable assignments while hiding a training need elsewhere.
Use matched groups where the company has enough history. Suppose one adviser receives forty technician referrals and ten web inquiries while another receives the reverse mix. Calculate each adviser’s close rate within referrals and within web inquiries. Then apply a shared hypothetical mix to both rates. The resulting comparison helps explain the assignment effect without claiming it precisely measures individual talent.
Review what happens after signature as well. An adviser selling discounted or heavily financed packages can post a strong close rate while the final installation margin suffers. Ask your installation manager about estimating errors, equipment substitutions and dealer fees by adviser. The contribution retained after installation often answers a purchase question more directly than the number of documents signed.
How do open estimates and cancellations change a monthly comparison?
Group opportunities by the month they were created and track when each reaches the endpoint. A January opportunity can close in February and complete in March. A January sales report grouped by closing date answers a different question from a January cohort report. Keep both views and reconcile them rather than forcing the same event into one undated percentage.
Create aging bands for open estimates. Check how many historically close within seven, thirty and sixty days, provided your data supports those observations. Compare a new cohort with older cohorts at the same age. If you compare ten-day results with fully matured opportunities, you can mistake normal sales-cycle timing for deterioration. Also preserve losses and cancellations so an old estimate cannot stay open indefinitely after the customer hires another installer.
For a purchase forecast, give incomplete opportunities an explicit probability and timing based on comparable history. Keep a signed contract awaiting equipment separate from a verbal expression of interest. A third-party finance approval, special-order component or local permit can delay completion even after the customer accepts the proposed scope.
What if conversion rises because the company stops issuing difficult estimates?
Look upstream at the people who never received proposals. A new manager may focus advisers on urgent calls and decline slow-moving or technically complex projects. The proposal-to-signature rate can rise while total completed jobs or contribution declines. Compare qualified leads, proposals, signed jobs and completed gross profit as actual counts alongside the percentages.
Check customer promises too. A salesperson may offer a faster install date than the crews can keep, producing signatures that later cancel. Review promised and actual installation dates and any discounts issued to settle complaints. If you plan to improve sales training, include the capacity required to deliver additional wins. Increasing conversion can create working-capital demands and warranty exposure before it produces cash available to the buyer.
How can you use the figure in a purchase model?
Start from the verified lead count, then apply the observed proposal, signing and completion rates in order. Multiply the resulting installations by realized job contribution and deduct any incremental overhead or sales expense. Use a downside case in which one stage declines while the others stay fixed. This shows whether the buyer’s biggest exposure is lead supply, adviser performance or crew availability.
Compare the model with the technician productivity calculator and use the technician roster to identify who is accountable for each handoff. Read the average ticket definition before applying an invoice average drawn from a different mix of work. Before an offer becomes exclusive, ask both parties to approve the dated opportunity export and the exact meaning of a sold job. That preserves a common denominator when the next reporting month closes.
For the first quarter after closing, keep a weekly exception list of unsigned proposals, signed jobs awaiting parts and completed jobs awaiting final approval. Give each line a next action and owner. A large balance in one stage can explain weak cash receipts even when the adviser’s reported close rate holds steady. A small number of old, high-value jobs can matter more to working capital than a large number of inexpensive inquiries.
Ask your adviser to show you an estimate that closed after your reporting cutoff. Trace which month gets the opportunity, which gets the signed sale and which gets the final invoice. Your forecast should preserve that timing even when you summarize the conversion rate.
Where can you go next?
What else should you know?
Should I count three equipment options as three opportunities?
Usually the three prices represent one customer decision. Give the opportunity one identifier and attach the alternative estimates to it. If the customer independently buys several systems or phases, document which decisions can close separately before adding more than one opportunity to the cohort.
What if the customer signs but later cancels?
Keep the original signature and the later cancellation as separate events. The transaction can count in a signed-sales metric while reducing the signed-to-completed rate. A buyer forecasting revenue or cash needs the final installation and collection records in addition to signed estimates.
Can I use the comfort adviser’s close rate for all service calls?
A comfort adviser generally receives a selected subset of calls. Apply that close rate only to the relevant opportunities after accounting for technician lead generation, appointment booking and proposal delivery. The full service-call population includes many calls with little reason for a replacement proposal.
Why review gross profit with conversion?
Salespeople can increase signatures through discounts, higher dealer fees or wider promises about included work. Compare actual equipment cost, installation labor, warranty allowances and fees to each completed invoice. The rate becomes financially meaningful when you know what contribution survives each additional sale.
Which sources informed this page?
- Contractor Playbook, residential field staff KPIs · ServiceTitan, November 21, 2026
- Dashboard business metrics and denominator definitions · ServiceTitan, November 21, 2026
- Technician Dashboard revenue report · ServiceTitan, November 21, 2026