HVAC Company Business BrokerBook a call
Menu
HedgeStone Business Advisors
Tool

Which HVAC acquisition offer pays you more?

Compare written offers by how much cash reaches you now, what could arrive later and which conditions you must meet. Enter the separate proceeds buckets, a timing assumption for each future payment and your expected collections. The resulting values let you compare offers with different headlines and different risk.

What do your numbers show?

Compare the cash you can use on closing day with the value you might collect later from up to three letters of intent.

Jump to results
Inputs
Offer 1
Offer 2

Your results

Offer 1 expected present value
$1,479,148
Offer 2 expected present value
$1,525,945

Closing cash already excludes escrow. A negative working-capital adjustment reduces your closing wire. Worst case assumes cash you receive at close is final; indemnity claims and operating guarantees can create further exposure.

Scenario comparison

Closing cash already excludes escrow.

Closing cashSeller note PVEarnout PVRollover PVEscrow PV
Offer 1Closing cash: $1,250,000Seller note PV: $97,329Earnout PV: $90,909Rollover PV: $0Escrow PV: $40,909Offer 2Closing cash: $1,050,000Seller note PV: $162,216Earnout PV: $136,364Rollover PV: $124,184Escrow PV: $53,182$0$1,525,945 (USD)Source: your current inputs and the calculation described below. Model reviewed November 21, 2026.
Chart data
Values shown in the scenario comparison
SeriesComponentValue
Offer 1Closing cash$1,250,000
Offer 1Seller note PV$97,329
Offer 1Earnout PV$90,909
Offer 1Rollover PV$0
Offer 1Escrow PV$40,909
Offer 2Closing cash$1,050,000
Offer 2Seller note PV$162,216
Offer 2Earnout PV$136,364
Offer 2Rollover PV$124,184
Offer 2Escrow PV$53,182
Offer proceeds before your taxes, debt and expenses
OfferHeadlineAt closingExpected todayZero deferred recovery
Offer 1$1,650,000$1,250,000$1,479,148$1,250,000
Offer 2$1,865,000$1,050,000$1,525,945$1,050,000
Email me these results

Assumptions and formulas

Expected value = closing cash plus working-capital adjustment plus the discounted expected recoveries on the note, earnout, rollover and escrow. Worst case assumes no deferred recovery. The note model is principal-only with one terminal payment; enter separate interest outside this model.

The initial fields are an illustrative composite. Replace them with records for your own business and use consistent periods.

This is an estimate, not an appraisal or valuation opinion.

How do you put three offers on one basis?

Start with a copy of each signed or draft letter of intent. Divide consideration into cash to you at completion, principal of any seller note, maximum contractual earnout, face value of equity you will roll and money withheld in escrow. Check whether the stated cash number already includes an amount that goes into escrow. Entering the gross cash and then adding escrow again creates a false increase in headline price.

Write the buyer’s working-capital adjustment separately. If the proposed peg requires you to leave more working capital than you expect to deliver, your closing proceeds can fall. Use a negative number for that shortfall. An estimated excess can increase proceeds if the agreement pays you for it. Keep company debt, personal tax and your advisory expenses for the net proceeds estimator.

Which future dollars deserve a lower weight?

Begin with the actual payment condition. A seller note depends on the buyer’s ability and obligation to repay you. Ask who signs the note, whether a senior lender can block payments, what collateral supports it and when principal is due. The simplified model assumes a single principal payment. For an amortizing note or regular interest, build a dated payment schedule separately.

Earnout value depends on both performance and control. An HVAC membership earnout can be tied to active accounts, renewed annual agreements or collected fees. Those tests give different results when a credit card fails, a customer changes plans, or a buyer changes pricing after closing. Estimate the probability of collecting the entered amount and save the reason. If the deal pays several tiers, calculate a probability-weighted total offline and enter that amount with full recovery probability.

What does the time adjustment actually do?

The calculator discounts each expected receipt from its assumed payment year back to closing. Use one consistent annual rate across offers when you want a clean comparison. The rate describes your time preference and risk assumptions. Avoid counting the same risk twice by using an extreme discount rate and an extreme probability haircut for the same concern.

How should you judge rollover equity and escrow?

Treat the rollover as an investment with its own outcome. Inspect the capital structure, preferred returns, debt, dilution protections and the order in which classes get paid at a later exit. A projected sale price for the entire platform says little about the distribution to your specific class. Enter your estimated terminal multiple on invested equity and the time you expect to wait. A zero return scenario shows the cost of a complete loss.

Escrow usually follows a different timetable and set of release conditions. Read which claims can reduce it and who decides a dispute. If the release is split across two dates, use a separately discounted cash-flow sheet for precision. The chart groups the components by source so you can see whether an apparently attractive offer depends on one difficult future event.

How can you use the comparison at the LOI stage?

Choose the amount of closing cash you need after paying obligations, then compare that need with the downside offer result. A buyer offering more contingent value might still be a fit if you can afford the delay and have the information rights to monitor progress. A shorter diligence period or a credible transition plan can matter even when the model produces similar present values.

  1. Reconcile every offer’s headline to its components.
  2. Run a collection case that you believe and a case in which every deferred payment fails.
  3. Note which clause changes your decision most.
  4. Ask counsel to negotiate the measurement, payment and dispute language for that clause.

Use the LOI comparison workbook to retain your assumptions alongside each written offer. Date the worksheet when a buyer revises the terms so that a change in payout timing does not disappear inside a larger headline number.

Which assumption should you negotiate first?

Look for a small contract change that would reverse your ranking. If delaying note principal makes another offer more attractive, inspect the maturity date and senior lender’s payment restrictions. If the difference comes from escrow, ask which claims suspend release and whether an undisputed balance is paid on time. If earnout measurement drives the result, confirm whether the buyer must provide records you can audit after you leave.

Give your attorney the exact clause and cash-flow assumption that changed your decision. A reporting right, payment date or release condition can be worth negotiating alongside the quoted headline. Save each updated offer with the date you received it so the final decision compares current terms across all bidders.

How do you compare offers that use different definitions of price?

Translate each letter of intent into an identical transaction boundary before deciding which offer is higher. Specify whether the price includes cash, debt, inventory, real estate, a normalized amount of working capital or a separate employment agreement. Two buyers can quote the same dollar amount while acquiring different assets and obligations.

Take a seller comparing a $5 million headline with another offer of $4.8 million. The first buyer expects all service inventory, an agreed amount of working capital and a substantial retention earnout. The second will pay separately for usable inventory and offers more cash at close. Begin with separate columns for included operating assets, separate asset purchases and consideration conditions. You cannot resolve the difference by adding the inventory value to both bids.

Then check which buyer pays the owner for post-close work. A salary for running the branch five days a week compensates the owner for future labor. Treating the full salary as purchase consideration can make the most demanding employment arrangement look like the richest sale. List the expected hours, term, benefits and ability to leave, alongside the acquisition economics.

Identify costs that apply to only one offer. One buyer might require an expensive environmental review, additional property work, a longer financing contingency or a seller-funded retention bonus. Record whether the cost is fixed, estimated, refundable or conditional. Ask the buyer to resolve ambiguity in writing before selecting an exclusive counterparty.

Where does risk sit when both buyers promise the same earnout?

Read the measurement definition, authority over operations and dispute procedure as a single package. A probability entered into the calculator is a judgment about those terms and the business. The judgment becomes more credible when you can reconstruct what would have happened under the proposed formula using a past period.

Consider a hypothetical earnout tied to retaining one thousand named memberships. One buyer counts paid renewals on an anniversary date. Another counts active subscriptions regardless of pending payments and may change the membership price immediately. Use the same historical roster to calculate both outcomes and inspect the accounts that land in different categories. The definition, pricing authority and treatment of delinquent accounts may drive a larger difference than the headline cap.

Test a missed threshold. Does payment fall smoothly with performance, disappear at a cliff or carry forward to another period? Identify who has access to supporting records and whether your review rights continue after leaving employment. If the buyer can move customers into a new legal entity, confirm how the formula will follow that activity. Your model should identify the unresolved contract point instead of turning a guess into a precise expected value.

Apply the same approach to notes and rollover equity. A note’s maturity date tells you when payment is due, while security, priority and covenants affect recovery. Rollover value depends on the security, capital structure, dilution, distributions and exit terms. Ask for a downside case where no early exit occurs and explain how that changes the seller’s ability to use the money.

How do you make the comparison useful at a negotiating meeting?

Bring one page of comparable economics and a short list of terms that would change the ranking. Give each buyer a concrete request. A seller seeking near-term liquidity might ask for a higher cash payment. A seller prepared to share operating risk might prefer better measurement rights and a lower payout threshold.

Suppose the seller expects two offers to produce similar discounted value but one requires another three years as operating manager. Ask whether that obligation fits the owner’s actual plans. Then price a realistic alternative for the labor. The company may need that executive regardless of who owns it, and the buyer should explain how it separated a fair wage from the price of the business.

Record the sensitivity of the ranking to one unresolved assumption at a time. Try a lower earnout result, slower note repayment or zero early rollover distribution. If the same offer remains attractive across those variations, the discussion can focus on closing certainty and transition terms. If one modest change reverses the ranking, seek further evidence or negotiate that specific provision before exclusivity.

Keep the signed letter and the model together as diligence progresses. A working-capital request can change, a retained liability can surface or the buyer’s financing plan can alter the timing. Record the date and reason for each revision. On the day you choose an offer, the version shown to your lawyer and accountant should match the version on which you made the decision.

Where can you go next?

What else should you know?

Should I put escrow in cash at closing?

Use only the dollars you can receive and use at closing in the immediate cash field. Put cash held by an escrow agent in the escrow field and set a release date. Checking that split against the draft sources-and-uses statement helps prevent the same dollars from appearing twice.

What does worst case include?

The table assumes no recovery on the seller note, earnout, rollover or escrow. It retains the modeled immediate cash and working-capital adjustment. Read your indemnities, guarantees and clawbacks separately because contractual claims can exceed held-back funds. The result is a defined downside scenario with assumptions you can inspect.

Is rollover at face value as good as cash?

Examine the class of equity you receive, the debt ahead of it, its transfer restrictions and its rights at an exit. You can enter the face value today, then test different exit proceeds and waiting periods. Your shares might pay nothing even when the operating company survives.

Can an offer with a smaller headline win?

Yes. A buyer can offer more closing cash, a shorter collection period or fewer payment conditions while quoting a lower maximum price. Compare your expected present value and your downside proceeds. Then consider whether the buyer can finance the transaction and accept the operating transition your shop needs.

Which sources informed this page?

Explore the selling hub