What should your HVAC quality-of-earnings engagement answer?
You want to know which earnings the business can defend, what cash those earnings consume and which obligations transfer with the sale. A report that repeats the seller’s adjusted EBITDA without inspecting jobs, cash collection or owner duties leaves those questions open. Define them in the engagement before you authorize a reviewer to collect documents.
Read the quality-of-earnings definition with your transaction team. A QoE engagement is usually focused diligence with an agreed scope. It can differ from an audit in procedures, purpose and assurance. Confirm the period, accounting basis, deliverables, access rights, intended users and limitations. A report commissioned by the seller may not give your buyer or lender the right to rely on it.
For a financed acquisition, ask your lender what it requires before selecting the provider. The SBA’s SOP 50 10 8.1 sets independent QoE requirements for certain initial or expansion transactions reaching its specified $3 million purchase-price threshold, with applicability and exceptions described in the procedures. Your lender needs the actual structure and purchase price to determine the applicable requirement. A report with the wrong scope or provider may leave work to repeat.
Which records make the engagement productive?
Gather the monthly trial balances, financial statements, tax returns and general ledger for the agreed periods. Add bank reconciliations, merchant settlements, payroll by role, vendor purchases and the asset register. A monthly export gives the reviewer a way to investigate whether a summer spike reflects weather, a single large job or a cutoff error. Annual tax returns alone cannot show that timing.
Then assemble operating evidence. Include completed and canceled jobs, invoices, credit memos, sold estimates, change orders, technician hours, maintenance agreements, membership billing and job-level direct cost. Preserve stable identifiers for customers, sites, jobs, invoices and payments. Early diligence can use anonymized identifiers where appropriate. Agree on controlled access to sensitive employee and customer details when deeper tests are warranted.
Use the data room index to record the system, report date, filters and responsible employee for every export. A service dashboard refreshed in November can reclassify work that appeared open in June. Save the original and subsequent versions so your reviewer can distinguish a historical change in facts from a software setting or later correction.
How do reviewers test whether HVAC revenue belongs in the period?
Select jobs recorded just before and after the reporting date. Match the signed estimate, equipment delivery, completed work, customer acceptance, invoice and collection. The relevant accounting period depends on the contract, performance and applicable policy. A payment in advance can create a deposit or deferred obligation. An unpaid invoice for completed work can still represent earned revenue under an accrual policy.
Test in both directions. Start with high-value invoices and find the actual jobs and costs. Then start with completed dispatch records and find the income statement entries. The first test can expose premature or duplicate revenue. The second can identify missing billing, crew time assigned to the wrong branch or repairs completed under an incorrectly coded membership visit.
Commercial construction needs additional evidence. Review job-to-date costs, estimated costs to complete, retainage, change orders and claims. Compare estimated margin at the report date with subsequent completion results. If the same estimator consistently understates subcontract labor, one job correction may signal a recurring forecast weakness. Ask your reviewers to distinguish the documented historical correction from their assessment of future estimating risk.
How do you test recurring memberships and technician economics?
Reconcile the membership population to settled payments and actual contract terms. Preserve unpaid renewals, grace periods, canceled plans and customers who only bought a discounted inspection. Calculate the direct cost of included visits, travel, parts, discounts and callback obligations. Annualized dues may help describe a book, but cash collected before performance and earned revenue in the period need separate schedules.
Sample service jobs for time and material cost. If the seller assigns parts when purchased rather than when used, monthly job margins can move with stocking decisions. If an installer’s labor is recorded in overhead, compare margins with a branch that includes field wages in cost of sales only after reconciling the classifications. Gross margin can change without changing total operating earnings.
Check the owner’s actual field work, sales, license supervision and management hours. An owner salary add-back followed by an inadequate replacement budget can inflate managed earnings. If a buyer plans to absorb the role through an existing regional manager, show that buyer-specific strategy separately. The seller’s standalone earnings and the buyer’s planned synergies answer different investment questions.
What does a finding change in a real price discussion?
Connect each finding to the specific line it changes, then trace the cash and balance-sheet effects. The example shows why multiplying every disputed item by the earnings multiple produces misleading numbers.
Illustrative composite — not a real client. A contractor presents adjusted EBITDA of $860,000. The reviewer tests a large equipment order, recurring warranty work and the founder’s management role. A $42,000 deposit was booked as revenue before the related work, with no corresponding costs recorded. Routine warranty labor of $28,000 was removed from earnings as unusual. A promised replacement manager costs $35,000 more than the seller allowed. A verified duplicate $14,000 freight charge should also be reversed.
| Finding | Change to starting earnings | Revised running total |
|---|---|---|
| Seller’s proposed earnings | Starting point | $860,000 |
| Advance booking unsupported in the period | −$42,000 | $818,000 |
| Restore recurring warranty labor | −$28,000 | $790,000 |
| Correct management compensation | −$35,000 | $755,000 |
| Reverse duplicate freight charge | +$14,000 | $769,000 |
The proposed reduction is $91,000. At an assumed 5.0 times earnings, a purely mechanical indication differs by $455,000. Your buyer should explain whether the deposit represents a timing issue or a recurring overstatement. If the job was subsequently completed, test the matching costs and rolling period rather than treating the deposit as a permanent loss every year. The obligation may also affect opening working capital.
Suppose a separate $60,000 collectible receivable will settle a month later than originally forecast. A timing delay can increase required working cash without reducing EBITDA by $60,000. If the customer disputes the bill, a reserve may be appropriate. The decision depends on evidence of collection and the agreement’s reserve policy. Track the receivable, cash need and potential earnings impact in separate columns until the treatment is clear.
Which findings deserve a second round of evidence?
Prioritize adjustments large enough to affect price, coverage or closing conditions and issues that recur across jobs. Request external support where available, including subsequent bank deposits, supplier credits, signed changes, payroll contracts and documented management offers. Apply the same standard to corrections that increase and reduce seller earnings. A one-sided schedule can appear persuasive until a buyer asks about unusual gains.
CLA’s sell-side diligence materials describe the value of identifying issues before a buyer begins its review. The SEC’s non-GAAP discussion supplies context for labeling EBITDA and additional adjustments. BDO’s working-capital guidance helps frame where balance-sheet questions belong. Your engagement’s own records still determine the treatment. Use the recast calculator to reproduce arithmetic, and attach source references to any material conclusion.
- Record the original amount and the exact period in which it was recognized.
- Identify the supporting transaction, operating job and subsequent settlement where relevant.
- State whether the finding changes earnings, delivered working capital, forecast cash or a contract term.
- Calculate the effect on the buyer, seller and lender cases independently.
- Agree who resolves the outstanding issue and when the work must be complete.
How do you use the report before and after closing?
Before signing, reconcile the seller’s presentation, the diligence report, the buyer’s final model and the lender’s calculation. Record the treatment of every item that changes more than one schedule. A buyer can negotiate a different price or risk allocation, but it should be able to identify the specific issue and the line where it first entered. If the same fleet concern appears in an earnings adjustment, a capital budget and a debt-like deduction, inspect the overlap.
At closing, preserve the trial balance, opening working-capital schedules, membership obligations and unresolved invoices so the incoming team can track the first months. Give operations managers the findings they can act on. If installation teams repeatedly missed a ductwork cost, update estimating and approval procedures. If billing closed jobs prematurely, fix the handoff between dispatch and finance. A good diligence file can improve the buyer’s first quarter as well as its purchase decision.
Ask the reviewer for a final list of unanswered questions and the documents that were unavailable. This helps you distinguish a known issue from a limitation on the analysis. A clean-looking conclusion based on incomplete branch data deserves a different degree of confidence from a reconciliation tested to the original jobs and subsequent deposits.
If you are the seller, ask your bookkeeper to reproduce one high-value adjustment without help from the report writer. If you are the buyer, ask your service manager what would have to change in the field for that adjustment to continue. Put both answers in your investment file. Your diligence becomes more practical when the people who own the ledger and the people who run the jobs can explain the same result in their own words.
Where can you go next?
What else should you know?
Will a QoE replace the buyer’s accountant or legal diligence?
The engagement covers the agreed financial questions and has its own limitations. It may identify issues requiring tax, legal, licensing or operational review. Confirm the intended users and reliance rights, then assign each uncovered issue to the adviser or employee with the relevant responsibility.
Why request both dispatch records and tax returns?
Tax returns provide annual reporting context. Dispatch records show jobs, dates, staff, cancellations and activity behind the totals. Matching both to the ledger and collections helps distinguish revenue timing, department coding and one-time items that an annual return alone cannot explain.
Can a completed sale be delayed by a lender’s QoE requirement?
Timing depends on the loan structure, current program rules, provider availability and quality of the records. Ask the lender early about its required scope and independence criteria. A seller-funded report can help preparation while still leaving lender-specific or buyer-specific work to be completed.
Should every QoE issue reduce the purchase price?
No. Some items change recurring earnings, some change closing working capital, and others affect timing or require a contractual remedy. Calculate the specific economic effect and check whether it is already reflected elsewhere before negotiating price, escrow or an additional closing condition.
Which sources informed this page?
- Sell-side quality of earnings engagement · CLA, November 21, 2026
- SOP 50 10 8.1, Appendix 15 · U.S. Small Business Administration, October 1, 2026
- Net working capital in mergers and acquisitions · BDO, November 21, 2026
- Non-GAAP financial measures, questions 100 and 103 · U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, November 21, 2026
