HVAC Company Business BrokerBook a call
Menu
HedgeStone Business Advisors
Guide

Checking an HVAC CIM against the dispatch book

Choose three claims that materially affect your offer and trace them from the confidential information memorandum into the dispatch system and accounting records. Start with completed revenue, technician capacity and repeat service work. Reconcile a full month, investigate exceptions and carry the unresolved dollars into your bid assumptions.

A closed transaction binder beside a dispatcher's job folders and a parked service van outside.

Which claims in an HVAC CIM should you verify first?

Start with the three claims that most affect what you are willing to pay. For a service and replacement contractor these often involve completed revenue, the technicians who produce it and the customers who return. Convert each claim into a question with an identifiable source record before requesting a large data room.

Imagine an owner presents $3.6 million in replacement sales, two crews capable of another installation per week and a strong flow of leads from maintained systems. Those three statements imply demand, capacity and a source of future opportunities. Each has a different unit of measurement. An accepted estimate measures a commitment. A dispatch assignment measures a planned use of time. A serviced address records activity at a location. None of those records by itself tells you what landed in the bank.

Write down what your model currently assumes. How much gross profit depends on replacement sales? Will additional payroll be necessary to reach the capacity forecast? What fraction of demand did you attribute to existing customers? The answers determine your sampling priorities. A beautifully presented membership chart deserves less immediate attention if the proposed price rests mainly on one installer crew and a large replacement backlog.

What should you request without making the owner rebuild the business?

Request native exports covering the same closed period, with stable identifiers that connect records across systems. Ask the controller or bookkeeper how the period was selected and whether a subsequent adjustment changed it. A seller can redact customer names while preserving job, invoice and location identifiers that make meaningful testing possible.

First-round records for a buyer checking a confidential memorandum
Claim under reviewRequestCross-check
Completed revenueClosed work orders with invoice numbers and creditsMonthly ledger sales and later reversals
Crew utilizationDispatch assignments, job dates and crew membersTimecards, overtime and callback visits
Member demandService locations, membership status at the job date and work typeAgreement history and replacement invoice
Collected cashReceipts and settlement identifiersBank deposits after fees and timing differences

Ask the person running the export to save the report settings as well as the file. A date range can refer to booking, completion, invoice, posting or payment. A report may exclude one business unit, show only active employees or count a return visit in a different department. If you cannot reproduce a number because nobody recorded its settings, a later rerun could produce a different answer even when the seller’s original statement was accurate.

Use your buyer due diligence workbook to label each request by decision. Give the seller a concrete alternative when a named export does not exist in their software. For instance, a dated job ledger with invoice identifiers can be sufficient to build an initial bridge. Insisting on a particular vendor’s report title can consume a week without adding evidence.

How do you reconcile a full month of jobs?

Build a bridge from all completed work in a selected month to the financial statement, then test selected jobs in both directions. The full-population bridge finds missing categories. Individual traces show whether the mapping you used is valid. One process should inform the other as you learn how the shop records its work.

  1. Select a month with a closed ledger and preserve the seller’s original files.
  2. Sum unique invoice lines by job type after removing sales tax and identifying credits under the seller’s accounting policy.
  3. Compare your totals with the relevant ledger accounts, including separately billed projects and membership income.
  4. Group differences by identifiable cause and ask for documentation on the largest items.
  5. Choose some jobs from dispatch and some entries from accounting, then trace each to its counterpart.

An illustrative month shows $340,000 in completed dispatch invoices and $355,000 in ledger revenue. Suppose you identify $24,000 of contract maintenance billed through a separate recurring process and $9,000 of prior-period job credits recorded in the ledger. Those reconciling items bring the two totals together. You still need to test whether the maintenance billing and credits belong to the selected dates. A zero difference on a spreadsheet can hide two unrelated mistakes of equal size.

Next select an invoice from an ordinary weekday repair. Match the dispatch completion, technician note, invoice and receipt. Then work backward from a large credit in the ledger. Find the customer complaint, returned equipment or finance cancellation that generated it. A seller-selected sample may consist entirely of clean, fully collected jobs. Your backward trace gives failures and adjustments a chance to enter the sample.

How can technician splits exaggerate the apparent crew capacity?

Rebuild one shared installation at company and employee level. Technician reports can assign shares of the same job to multiple people or credit an employee for selling work completed by someone else. Before adding individual figures, determine what each column measures and whether its allocations sum to a meaningful company total.

Suppose a $12,000 installation needs a lead and a helper over two days. Both appear on the work order. A sales report also credits a comfort advisor with the accepted estimate. If you combine three exports by job number alone, your worksheet can repeat the invoice value on every row. Start with unique invoice lines, retain employee assignments in a separate table and apply the actual technician splits when you report individual results.

Compare the reconstructed calendar with paid hours. Include supplier trips, warranty visits, training, travel and the time that a lead spent supervising a less experienced installer. Your buyer model may assume a second crew can absorb another weekly job. Identify who would lead it, which truck it would use and which existing calls would lose coverage. The technician productivity tool gives you a way to vary available hours without counting the same person twice.

Look closely at gaps. A blank afternoon might represent available capacity. It might also mean the installer still worked on a project whose dispatch card closed at midday. Match that day to a timecard, the installation notes and the next appointment. Your goal is to understand whether the estimate of spare hours survives contact with the shop’s actual workweek.

What proves the stated member-to-replacement channel?

Link the sale to a customer location with a qualifying agreement already in force when the opportunity arose. Then check the lead origin, diagnosis, accepted estimate and completed replacement. An agreement sold on installation day should appear as a new customer relationship in the forward-looking book. It does not independently establish that a prior membership generated the installation.

Do the test on a sample of large replacement jobs and a sample of maintenance visits. Starting only from completed installations makes the channel look stronger because unsuccessful opportunities vanish. Starting only from visits makes it hard to see which recommendations ultimately became paid work. Preserve both sets and check how many maintenance recommendations are still open, expired, canceled or won by another contractor.

Check for commercial properties with multiple units at one address. The shop might have maintained a rooftop unit at the rear of a building while a different vendor installed the unit named in the replacement invoice. An address match can support follow-up, but it cannot establish the equipment relationship on its own. Equipment tags, model numbers, technician notes and the date of the recommendation help you decide which opportunities belong in the verified cohort.

How should the findings change your offer?

Attach the few unresolved differences that could change your valuation to a priced assumptions schedule. State the claim, the record you could verify, the potential cash effect and what would resolve it. Set an agreed time for the seller’s answer so both sides understand when a tentative assumption becomes a bidding decision.

If a discrepancy moves revenue from June to July with no loss of cash or margin, show both dates and repair the monthly forecast. If it represents repeated cancellations after consumer financing fails, adjust the conversion assumption and test collections. If it represents work done by an owner who plans to retire, address replacement labor separately. Your guide to reading the HVAC P&L helps you carry those findings into the right financial line.

Finally, retain who ran each report, the date, the account filters and the version used for your offer. At a later meeting the seller may produce a more complete export after closing an accounting period. Put the new and old totals beside one another and explain the movement. That discipline lets the people reviewing your buying plan distinguish a better set of records from a changed business and make the next decision on evidence both sides recognize.

Review the exception that concerns your lender most with the person who actually closed the job. A junior dispatcher may know that the team uses a temporary completion code to release an installer for the next assignment. An outside accountant may know that the code feeds an overnight posting batch. If each explains only their own system, the combined process can remain invisible. Follow the transaction across the handoff with both people present and preserve the resulting reconciliation.

If the seller cannot reproduce an important claim, ask whether you could base the offer on a smaller, verifiable figure while leaving room to revisit the difference. An offer supported by two documented crews and measured demand gives both sides something concrete to negotiate. Put the extra crew in a separate case until its staffing, truck and work orders can be demonstrated.

Where can you go next?

What else should you know?

Can I verify the seller’s dispatch book before signing an NDA?

Ask for a description of the available systems and redacted, aggregate figures at that stage. Individual service records can reveal customer identities and commercially sensitive activity. Agree on appropriate confidentiality and access with the seller, then choose an anonymized sample that permits cross-checking without exposing unnecessary personal information.

How many invoices should I ask to see first?

Choose enough different job types to test the actual claims that support your price, then reconcile the population for at least one complete period. A handful of selected invoices can demonstrate the workflow. They cannot independently establish a full-year error rate, so expand your testing where discrepancies cluster.

What if the technician dashboard and the accounting report disagree?

First check whether the reports cover the same event, period and amount. A split-adjusted technician metric and company-level invoice total can both be correct. Reconstruct one affected job, inspect the posting event and ask the bookkeeper to identify the corresponding accounting entry before classifying the difference as an error.

Should I reduce my offer for every open item?

Separate differences that merely move between periods from recurring earnings problems and uncollectible balances. Estimate the effect once, identify where it belongs in purchase economics, and give the seller a chance to produce evidence. Change your offer when the remaining uncertainty matters to cash flow, financing or operating capacity.

Which sources informed this page?

Explore the buying hub